This article was originally posted on Moonhill Indonesia (moonhill.id) on July 13, 2020. {alertInfo}
FIKSI.NET — I could not talk about this game without spoiling the story and major plot.
Even though, I don't think spoiler alert has any effect anymore since the game
was leaked before the release. But, I assume some people didn't know anything
about this game and for the sake of decency (yeah, I still care about being
decent even though I keep failing), I will put a spoiler alert here... Feel
free to leave this post if you do not want to see any spoiler before you play
the game yourself after this notice below. Proceed with caution.
This review contains MAJOR spoiler! Please proceed with caution! {alertWarning}
Now let us continue. I'm writing this post spontaneously––like most of my
blog posts––so bear with me, and let me know in the comment section below if
I miss any point I should mention. I will try my best to not miss any major
issue with this game though. And as a friendly reminder, keep the comment
section civil (as if people will be commenting on my unpopular post anyway).
Thank you.
{tocify} $title={Table of Contents}
I Used to Hate This Game
I have to admit, I used to hate this game, and I disagree with most of the
creative direction that Neil Druckmann and Naughty Dog are going with the
story. No, it's not because Ellie is gay, I played
The Last of Us: Left Behind back on my Playstation 3, I know that
she's gay already. I don't know why some people are surprised, probably no
one really noticed that DLC, which is.... weird at this point. If people
really enjoy The Last of Us, I assume they also played Left Behind,
since in that DLC we get to play Ellie more.
I hated this game because my friend told me about the leak before the game
release,
that we are going to play half of the game as Abby, someone who killed
Joel and going to beat up Ellie somehow. I had no idea about it, and all I can imagine was the worst thing
possible; THE LAST OF US PART II IS NOT GOING TO BE FUN. I really love
Ellie, she's my numero uno favorite game character. The last thing I
want for Ellie is to play as someone who's going to kill her or hurt her. I
am being Joel for a second here. I mean, I love her lame jokes and nerdy
introverted personality.
![]() |
Ellie (left) and Joel (right) |
So yeah, I don't care if Joel dies or not, I care only for Ellie.
The only intention I have in mind to play The Last of Us Part II is to
play Ellie and Ellie alone.
I'm not expecting to play Abby. Let alone play as a character who's
going to hurt my most favorite character by killing his father figure
(emotionally) and beating her up (physically). I was already disappointed by
both things that I was expecting and not expecting before playing the game.
So, I thought I won't play this game, and I wanted to wait for someone, like
PewDiePie, play this game and watch them. That's just one thing I hated
about this game that I don't particularly agree with the choices that the
creator makes––even now, I don't think I agree with them completely. I don't
know about you but I saw people (including me) expressed their feelings to
Naughty Dog to make The Last of Us Part II because they are hoping to play
as Ellie as much as we play as Joel in the first game.
The second thing that makes me disliked this game, came after I play the
game myself. THE PACING OF THIS STORY IS A MESS.
I don't know for sure what they were thinking when they wrote the scripts,
the pacing makes the story does not come as powerful. Even though I
don't mind if Joel has to die in this game, I assume they try to make us
feel what Ellie feels, but I think there are better ways to kill Joel
without making him acting out of character. Joel was always cautious towards
strangers, but maybe he is slowly changing because he lives in Jackson, and
people in Jackson are basically learning to gain their humanity back (you
can find it written on a note when you play the game). If that really needs
to happen, I think it's better if they show us how Joel is changed first,
how he got to be who he was before he got killed by a stranger he trusted.
The third reason, although it's just my observation, the way Naughty Dog
and Neil Druckmann
lied about this game.
How this game was marketed was very misleading. People followed every news,
every update about The Last of Us Part II before it came out, and that's
because they really care and attached with the characters. There are already
some expectations, and things they do not expect to see. Like it or not, we
must admit that those lies and expectations get in the way of seeing what
this game actually is.
After I Played the Game
I wanted to play this game simply to witness and tried to be "open-minded"
about it. I gave this game the benefit of the doubt. So, I bought it, played
it. After a while though, I started to see there are only 2 reasons left for
me to dislike from this game; (1) the pacing is a mess, and (2) they still
lied about this game. I don't hate Abby as much as I thought I would hate
her. I'm starting to see where she is coming from and how she's changed in
the end. I want them to continue with Abby and Ellie's story somehow, maybe
not a game format, but with the HBO series. I still love Ellie, nevertheless.
I understand that sometimes it's hard to forgive someone, especially when
you trust them so much and you look up to them.
![]() |
Dina (left) and Ellie (right) |
I didn't hate this game as much as I used to. I like it, I love it even. The
gameplay is great. It's NOT perfect, this game is flawed. I just think they
should have not made this story in a game format at all, or if they do, they
could make 2 parts of the story for part 2 and call it a trilogy. There is
too much to digest. If I can write this story, I would make Part II focused
on Ellie's life in Jackson, bonding with Dina and Jesse, also her journey to
discover the truth that Joel hides. On Abby's side, also the same, her life
with WLF and the war with Seraphites/Scars... (suddenly it sounds boring and
weird to me) I don't know... just fix the time jump. Maybe just tell the
story in chronological order, just like the first game. After all, we know
that's how we know where Joel was coming from; a father who lost his
daughter.
What I Like About This Game
What I like about this game is... weirdly enough, the story. I feel like
Joel, Ellie, Abby, and even Abby's father, they all just try to do what they
THINK they have to do to FIND peace within themselves––which
currently is the journey I'm in. If Abby thought she was going to get
closure from his father's death by killing Joel, Joel also
selfishly lied to Ellie and doomed humanity along with it because he
couldn't overcome his grief and trauma over his daughter's death. Ellie
however, thought she could move on from Joel's death by killing Abby, and
I'm glad she didn't kill Abby at the end, instead try to forgive her just
like how she tries to forgive Joel too.
What about Joel's death? So, I changed my mind about how he died. I think
Jackson makes him change somehow. Because many survivors coming to Jackson,
just like in the note you found in the game:
![]() |
Letter from Seth |
This note was written by Seth, he is the one who gives Ellie a sandwich as a
peace offering before she and Dina heading out. Surely, after many strangers
come to town to seek refuge, people in Jackson starting to ease their guard.
Tommy introduced himself after Mel (Abby's friend) kindly/harmlessly told
him her name, and then Joel followed.
I think the way Mel trusted them, makes Tommy and Joel trusted Abby and
her friends, even offered them to go to Jackson to get supplies.
Also, when people say they feel the need to give Joel a redemption arc, I
want them to ask why the first game happens in the first place instead. I
think he's unredeemable in the first place. He lives long enough to see
himself become the villain to Ellie. I remember what he said to Ellie, "if
somehow the Lord give me a second chance,
I will do it ALL OVER AGAIN." Something like that...
My take on what Joel said is this; he doesn't feel remorse, nor he feels the
need to reevaluate his life and what he has selfishly done to the people he
loves. Joel does what he does because he cannot move one, his biggest flaws
from the first game. Ellie also has flaws, she's unable to forgive. Ellie
witnessing Joel's death is somehow as an insight of what she's going to be
when she could not overcome her biggest flaw; her inability to forgive.
Joel's downfall almost becomes Ellie's downfall if she kills Abby at the end
of the story. If not Lev, maybe someone else will make Ellie pays for what
she has done.
Final Notes
Anyway, this is shorter than I thought it would be. I think they shouldn't
talk about anything regarding this game in the beginning. Let people
speculate all they want, no need to deny anything from any fans anyway, and
stop the misleading marketing bullshit. I don't see trailers nor follow
updates about the game I'm waiting because the game news and fandom can be
toxic at some point. If you don't like the game, I get it. This game is not
for everybody. If you like the game, I get you too. I've been on both sides,
but I choose to be in the middle. I want to enjoy things I like and have no
personal issues with and use my pitchfork where it's supposed to be; the
barn and when the zombie apocalypse really happens.
I have the right to translate this story that makes sense to me, you might
agree if you also believe that Video Game is art. Fortunately for me, I can
rationalize why this game is the one we get. I disagree with the misleading
marketing though, they clearly lied a lot about this game. Maybe
because I have no expectation on this game other than I could play Ellie, I also didn't follow any news or updates about this game, I can easily
let things be where most people cannot.
At FIKSI.NET,
we are committed to creating authentic, human-crafted content with minimal
reliance on AI.
If you enjoy what we do and would like to support our mission of promoting
Asian fiction, consider joining our email newsletter for updates or supporting
us financially.
Every bit of encouragement helps us continue sharing these incredible stories
with the world. Thank you for being part of our journey!
Tags:
Review